« Should immigration be family-based? | Main | Glenn Hubbard favors tradeable permits over a carbon tax »
Are You a Good Liar?
Are you a good liar? Most people think that they are, but in reality there are big differences in how well we can pull the wool over the eyes of others. There is a very simple test that can help determine your ability to lie. Using the first finger of your dominant hand, draw a capital letter Q on your forehead.
Some people draw the letter Q in such a way that they themselves can read it. That is, they place the tail of the Q on the right-hand side of their forehead. Other people draw the letter in a way that can be read by someone facing them, with the tail of the Q on the left side of their forehead. This quick test provides a rough measure of a concept known as "self-monitoring". High self-monitors tend to draw the letter Q in a way in which it could be seen by someone facing them. Low self-monitors tend to draw the letter Q in a way in which it could be read by themselves.
High self-monitors tend to be concerned with how other people see them. They are happy being the centre of attention, can easily adapt their behaviour to suit the situation in which they find themselves, and are skilled at manipulating the way in which others see them. As a result, they tend to be good at lying. In contrast, low self-monitors come across as being the "same person" in different situations. Their behaviour is guided more by their inner feelings and values, and they are less aware of their impact on those around them. They also tend to lie less in life, and so not be so skilled at deceit.
Long time readers will not be surprised to learn that I find it difficult to see things from other people's perspective and thus, consistent with the theory, I am a lousy liar!
More here. Hat tip to Koettke.
Posted by Alex Tabarrok on May 31, 2007 at 07:15 AM in Science | Permalink
Comments
Or you might be lying about this :)
Posted by: bluematter.blogspot.com at May 31, 2007 8:32:27 AM
One of the most important requirements for deception is for others to think you incapable of it.
Hence this post is a ruse.
Or is it?...
Posted by: KevinM at May 31, 2007 8:33:31 AM
I am either a good liar or dyslexic.
Posted by: Blar at May 31, 2007 8:52:52 AM
bluematter, KevinM - There's an easy way to find out. Let's get Alex to draw a Q on his forehead with a magic marker and have Tyler snap a picture (or better, shoot a video) and post it!
Posted by: Ironman at May 31, 2007 9:45:33 AM
Kink-in-theory time:
-I'm a bad liar.
-When planning the Q, I planned to put the tail on the right side.
-I can easily see things from others' perspective. (At least on economic issues ... not so much social settings.)
Hm ... maybe I'm a better liar than I thought ... or I'm overstating the extent to which I see things
from other's perspectives.
Or this just more BS pop psychology.
Posted by: Person at May 31, 2007 10:22:24 AM
Hmm. I drew the Q to my left, I am usually good at seeing things from other people's perspective, and though I don't generally lie, based on some manipulation of my parents during my teenage years I'm not bad at it.
So from my perspective it works. :)
Posted by: Tracy at May 31, 2007 10:28:15 AM
So having empathy makes you a good liar in addition to being more helpful? Ok folks, don't trust anyone offering to help.
I wonder how many people lie and say they have the Q readable for others? Or lie and say they have it readable for only themselves? It's enough to scramble my brain. Not.
Posted by: happyjuggler0 at May 31, 2007 11:27:45 AM
Or if you could lie but never do so are otherwise unskilled or at least unwilling.
Posted by: Lord at May 31, 2007 11:46:58 AM
What about left-handed people?
Posted by: Kieran at May 31, 2007 11:50:03 AM
I wrote Q with the tail first towards right, but suddenly became conscious of others watching me and so re-wrote Q with tail towards the left. So I am a 50% liar.
Posted by: GVV at May 31, 2007 11:53:57 AM
Of course, there's an alternative way to lie convincingly, if you're not good at monitoring how you're perceived. If you are able to temporarily persuade yourself that the lie is true, the external behavior takes care of itself without the need for self-monitoring. So an active and flexible imagination would seem to make for a good liar, as well.
Posted by: LP at May 31, 2007 12:13:19 PM
The level of genius I'm up against? I asked my wife to do this & she looked at me quizzically & asked, "Well, do you want it oriented to you or to me?"
Posted by: kebko at May 31, 2007 5:28:49 PM
I had the tail on the right side, but my prefered tactic for lying that I established in my teen years was lie poorly (not deliberately making mistakes, but simply not putting much effort into the deception) about trivial matters so that my parents thought that I was a bad liar, making it easier to fool them in situations where the costs of my deception being found out would be higher.
Posted by: MattXIV at May 31, 2007 6:04:28 PM
It's not about being unaware of one's impact on others. It's about not caring what they think about you. If you are true to yourself, there's absolutely no need to lie to others anyway.
But they still might think you are lying, and thus think you're a "bad" liar. Even when you're just telling them the truth.
Posted by: donna at May 31, 2007 8:25:53 PM
A friend of mine chose the method of telling the truth in such a way that he was never believed. Even if he was caught out... well he did say the truth.
On the other hand, playing the card game "Liar", he was sometimes able to pull 12 or 16 aces out of a single pack of cards.
Posted by: doctorpat at May 31, 2007 8:50:13 PM
This won't work on anyone younger than 25. They all grew up calling people losers by making an "L" out of their thumb and forefinger and holding it up to their foreheads. Having the L point at yourself (making you the loser) instead of at the other person is the rookiest of rookie mistakes. No one makes it twice.
Posted by: David J. Balan at May 31, 2007 11:08:59 PM
hey this is interesting ...If this theory is true then i am a High
self-monitoring one.Want to have more of such analysis thru blogs.
Posted by: Offshore Software Product Testing at Jun 1, 2007 2:57:21 AM
Is it this simple to analyise and evaluate this fact.I don't think so..
Posted by: Outsourced Product Development Center at Jun 1, 2007 3:00:38 AM
Well i can things with thers perspective very cooly.And wrote Q having
its tail towards the left side of my forehead.so very true in my case!!
Posted by: Smart Card Development Solutions Consultancy at Jun 1, 2007 3:12:58 AM
Remember, it isn't a lie if you believe it.
Posted by: George Costanza at Jun 1, 2007 2:08:41 PM
David J. Balan,
I must admit, I have never understood how putting an "L" on one's own forehead implies that someone else is the loser, regardless of which hand you use.
Posted by: Yancey Ward at Jun 1, 2007 2:13:07 PM
I wrote the Q properly with regard to the "writing medium", i.e. my forehead. I wasn't thinking of others at all. So IMO this isn't much of a test.
LP offers the true path to being able to lie convincingly; you have to "believe" the lie yourself, for the duration of the action it depends on. It's not at all unlike acting.
Posted by: Seerak at Jun 4, 2007 6:28:16 PM
if you could lie but never do so are otherwise unskilled or at least unwilling.
Posted by: artist brush at Nov 17, 2007 9:05:25 PM
hi,
After graduation ,I very like design ,so I had an室內設計 recruitment company .We division meticulous, and cooperation and teamwork is a very good company.Work very happy ,I am primarily responsible for the design of indoor soft傢俱.
About two years of work .Because my father work to mobilize, to take care of his elderly mother's grandfather, his grandmother, we had to another city搬家 the whole family,Because original companies too far from home, Very convenient to work,I consider again
I had to abandon the original work,i found in the 翻譯社 of a work now,I like the translation work is also.I will work hard and hope that understanding more friends.
Refueling!Refueling!Refueling!
Posted by: Jeery at Dec 4, 2007 2:22:27 AM
大家好,我是臺灣人,從臺灣一個人搬家來到美國,環境很陌生,感覺很孤單。以前在臺灣幾家知名的徵信社工作過,我是一個優秀的徵信工作者,希望早點找到適合自己的工作。希望通過貴站,認識更多的朋友。
Posted by: 謝文豪 at Apr 2, 2008 3:45:10 AM