« Dynamic public finance models | Main | Cultural Amnesia »

Digital currency with meta information

A loyal MR reader asks:

What is currency and what are the potential implications of a completely digital currency that could have unlimited meta information attached to it? [Some obvious implications would be tracking transactions and the government's ability to enforce taxes, etc., some more esoteric stuff would be attaching conditions much like covenants, say that a particular payment could only be used to buy products that were carbon neutral, possibly down the road having policy implications.]

Higher taxes and carbon offsets we've already covered.  More generally, the use of "covenant currency," as I shall call it, would raise prices.  Restricted money simply isn't worth as much.  It also would lead to a secondary market in currency.  Say you paid with me with money that can only be used to buy corn from Africa.  I'll try to resell that money to the people who were going to buy corn in Africa anyway.  Of course the supply of targeted covenant money for that end may exceed the demand for it, and then price will adjust; think of this as an extreme form of legal tender laws.

Would it ever be efficient to use covenant money?  I doubt it.  It is a tax -- on the holding and use of cash balances -- when a simple transfer would do.  Use regular money for your transactions and, if you wish, send some cash to the corn sellers of Africa.

Inflation is also a tax on cash balances, and few people think that is the right or the best fiscal way to finance subsidies to various worthy groups.

#11 in a series of 50.

Posted by Tyler Cowen on March 3, 2007 at 06:02 AM in Economics | Permalink

Comments

Isn't this exactly what gift cards are?

Posted by: Dennis Mangan at Mar 3, 2007 8:35:40 AM

So you answered 1/3rd of the question (with a pretty good answer, I think). What about "what is currency?" and "what are the implications of a completely digital currency [whatever that is]?"?

Posted by: billb at Mar 3, 2007 4:31:28 PM

You'd also get serious Gresham's Law action, with the most restricted and marked-up cash circulating, while people hoarded the most useful stuff. Plus "Regulatory pollution" -- the circulating money supply would get more and more bizarrely and assortedly marked up, to the point that you might need to ponder a dozen different sets of restrictions to buy a 25-cent gumball.

Posted by: Grant Gould at Mar 3, 2007 7:28:00 PM

covenant currency = government issued Correct? For your answer above do you mean that would be government issued digital currency?

completely digital currency = Digital Gold Currency

http://www.e-gold.com
http://www.pecunix.com
etc.

Privately issued digital has all of the advantages with none of the downside, yet.

Posted by: Mark Herpel at Mar 3, 2007 7:40:52 PM

Tyler,
Surprised by your answer, I checked in google and the only good reference to "covenant currency" is in p. 14 of
http://www.reformationmedia.org/main/newsletter/December_06.pdf
As you can see it is a gift card.
I'm sure the question posed to you refer to electronic currency as discussed in wikipedia (see also the entries "alternative currency" and "digital gold currency"). Indeed electronic currency is not a gift card and raises some of the interesting issues detailed in the question to you.

Posted by: Edgardo at Mar 4, 2007 12:59:03 AM

Let me add to my previous post and answer to the person that asked you the question, that in principle the use of an electronic currency to pay for a gift card is not different from using cash, debit cards, or credit cards.

Posted by: Edgardo at Mar 4, 2007 1:09:45 AM

Surely the downside of privately issued currency is that the issuer is unregulated, and may go bust/refuse to redeem your currency/hyperinflate it etc.

Posted by: Peter Clay at Mar 4, 2007 7:11:02 AM

Peter Clay, everything you say in reference to private-issued currencies and much more can happen with government-issued currencies--in the past 50 + years the Argentinian government has shown to Argentinians and economists (and I happen to be an Argentinian economist) the many ways to abuse the monopoly power of currency.

Posted by: Edgardo at Mar 4, 2007 10:35:12 AM

Hmm. Well, it does have the effect of subsidizing cash payments to corn suppliers in Africa. If the supply of "African-corn-money" was way high, then corn-buyers would have the option of buying the cheaper "African-corn-money" to buy the African corn, instead of say, American corn. That's just a subsidy.

On the other hand, this can be handled more simply through some mechanism like the "energy credits" example, where people can "buy" African corn credits even if they don't buy African corn. Then you just need to make sure credits get minted properly (no double counting, etc.), and you should be fine.

The supply curve for the African corn money turns into a demand curve for African corn credits. (I dunno, maybe you still call this a supply curve).

Posted by: mk at Mar 4, 2007 7:46:56 PM

This was my question, and once again let me say that I think it is a really great idea to go through 50 questions like this. Perhaps I am biased, but I think there is more to this, and it appears some of the commenters have picked up on that and agree.

Just to pick an example, one of the effects of regulation or taxes is to push economic activity under the table. With digital currency, it appears to me at least that the cost/benefits/enforcement issues could be drastically different. It could usher in authoritarianism, or it could make pigouvian taxes workable.
On the idea of covenant currency, I would imagine that a market in covenents would emerge, and instead of government as a proxy for the people issuing subsidies, individuals could choose their own restrictions.
Other intriguing scenarios emerge - say an anti child labor group lobbying Visa, or a credit card consortium, to attach no child labor agreements to everything that they clear.
I have in no way figured out any of the actual implications, but by considering what currency at root is, and what it performs, I can imagine some innovative ways to use the the power of markets.

Posted by: theCoach at Mar 5, 2007 9:22:05 AM

I also meant to add that I look forward to any commenters responses.

Posted by: theCoach at Mar 5, 2007 9:23:10 AM

I have made a brief comment here: http://stonecity.blogspot.com/2007/03/aversion-therapy.html

Posted by: sammler at Mar 6, 2007 12:11:53 PM


Sex Toys Vibrators

Choosing an Online Adult Sex Toys Shop can be quite overwhelming. With literally thousands of online adult sex toy shop offering an abundance of adult sex toys it can be a very stressful process when all you are looking for is to relieve some stress. There are several key factors when choosing an adult sex toy shop. It's essential that you follow these adult sex toy buying tips to ensure your complete overall satisfaction. The first step in choosing an online adult sex toys shop is how many years has the company been in business.


sex toys vibrators
sex toys vibrators

sextoys vibrators
sextoys vibrators
Penis Extension sex toys
Penis Extension sex toys

sex toys Vibrators
sex toys Vibrators

waterproof vibrators
waterproof vibrators

sex toys vibrators
sex toys vibrators

Too many adult sex toys companies , like other companies are scams or are run by individuals. After being in the adult industry several years, I have personally discovered the better companies are the ones still around. A company's reputation is key, and if you don't mind discussing it with friends, it may not be a bad idea to get adult toy store recommendations so when you buy sex toys. Otherwise if you are too shy, I highly suggest ready adult forums, or adult sex toy forums. These adult toy store forums or adult sex toy blogs are great to get user recommendations. Next choose an adult sex toy shop that offers an abundance of adult products such n lubes, lotions, strap ons, anal sex toys, butt plugs, lingerie, vibrators, dildos etc.

Strap on dildos sex toys
Strap on dildos sex toys

sex toys dildos
sex toy dildos

huge dildos sex toy
huge dildos sex toy

Rabbit Vibrators sex toys
Rabbit Vibrators sex toys

lovedolls sex toys
lovedolls sex toys

This complete adult toy selection will allow you to compare products to ensure it's the perfect toy for you. Make sure you know the adult toy manufacturer names and is made by a reputable adult toy manufacturer. Two major adult toy store are Cal Exotic Novelties and Doc Johnson Sex toys. These two are one of the biggest and most respected names in the adult industry. While, there are others great manufacturers too at least make sure the adult toy store you are buying carries them. Don't get fooled by the price game when buying adult toys.


realistic dildos sex toy
realistic dildos sex toy

sex toy realistic vaginas
sex toy realistic vaginas

anus sex toy
anus sex toy

sex toy Penis Pumps
sex toy Penis Pumps

sex toy Cock Rings
sex toy Cock Rings

Blowjob sex toys
Blowjob sex toys

It's essential you choose an adult sex toys shop for the overall quality and completeness of the site. Make sure that a majority of the links work and are fast loading. This will show you how detailed oriented an adult sex toys shop may be. There you have it. Follow these little tips when buying your adult sex toys and you are on your way to some really great fun. SexToys Vibrators is the leading online adult sex toys shop. America's favorite place to buy sex toys. Sex Toys Vibrators is dedicated to provided the hottest selling adult sex toys and is 100% Discreet and committed to customer satisfaction.


sex toy Masturbators
Masturbators

anal sex toy
anal sex toy

sex toy butt plugs
butt plugs

adult Sex Games
adult Sex Games

adult Lubrication
adult Lubrication

condoms sex toys
condoms sex toys

myspace porn
myspace porn
myspace porn site
myspace porn site
adult myspace
adult myspace
adult myspace
adult myspace
adult social networking site
adult social networking site
adult social networking
adult social networking
adult social networking site
adult social networking site
adult social networking
adult social networking
adult friends
adult friends
adult community
adult community
adult blogs
adult blogs
adult chat
adult chat
adult social networking
adult social networking
adult auctions
adult auctions
adult auction
adult auction
adult online auction
adult online auction
adult video auction
adult video auction
adult toys auction
adult toys auction
adult movie auction
adult movie auction
adult website auction
adult website auction
adult website business
adult website business
turnkey adult website
turnkey adult website
start adult website
star adult website
adult website for sale
adult website for sale
own an adult web site
own an adult web site
auctions adult
auctions adult
erotic lingerie
erotic lingeie
erotic art
erotic art
adult jewlery
adult jewlery
adult novelties
adult novelties
adult books
adult books
used panties
used panties
mens clothing
mens clothing
adult magazines
adult magazines
adult business
adult business
adult services
adult services
tickets online
tickets online
live ticket broker
live ticket broker
sports ticket broker
sports ticket broker
available sports event tickets
available sports event tickets
book theater tickets
book theater tickets
concert ticket broker
concert ticket broker
live concert tickets
live concert tickets
buy concert tickets
buy concert tickets
concert tickets online
concert tickets online
broadway theater tickets
broadway theater tickets
broadway show theater tickets
broadway show theater tickets
sex shop
sex shop
sport tickets
sport tickets
adult toys
adult toys
adult sex toy
adult sex toy
buy adult sex toys
buy adult sex toys

Posted by: toy at Jun 10, 2007 2:50:44 AM

大家好,我是臺灣人,從臺灣一個人搬家來到美國,環境很陌生,感覺很孤單。以前在臺灣幾家知名的徵信社工作過,我是一個優秀的徵信工作者,希望早點找到適合自己的工作。希望通過貴站,認識更多的朋友。

Posted by: 謝文豪 at Apr 2, 2008 1:47:25 AM

Post a comment