« The European Economy Since 1945 | Main | For the curious »

Does downward nominal wage rigidity matter?

Michael Elsby says no.  In his view, if downward nominal wage stickiness is a potential problem, the relevant class of firms will simply start workers off at a lower nominal wage, raising it over time as need be.  The result will be "wage compression."

Elsby also claims that the Phillips curve trade-off between inflation and unemployment is not stronger at low levels of price inflation.  That suggests that nominal wage rigidity doesn't much matter at the macro level.  If it did, proximity to that zero nominal cut point ought to boost the benefits of inflation, but it doesn't seem to.

I am surprised by this argument, but I don't (yet?) see reason to reject it.

Posted by Tyler Cowen on November 8, 2006 at 07:56 AM in Economics | Permalink

Comments

if downward nominal wage stickiness is a potential problem, the relevant class of firms will simply start workers off at a lower nominal wage, raising it over time as need be. The result will be "wage compression."

That sounds a little oversimplified. Does it imply that wages in general are lower than they would be if there were no stickiness?

Can this be tested by some sort of comparison between high-inflation (nominal stickiness not too important) and low-inflation (nominal stickiness a constraint) environments?

Posted by: bernard Yomtov at Nov 8, 2006 10:33:47 AM

The firms that are facing downward wage pressure are likely to be trying to layoff workers rather than hire new workers at any wage.

Also, new workers are not a perfect substitute for existing workers, and hiring new workers may not be a good solution to wage stickiness for all firms.

Posted by: mobile at Nov 8, 2006 12:40:04 PM

The argument, at least in the form you present it, seems to assume that firms have accurate knowledge of their exposure to future shrinking profit margins. Insofar as they do, they can factor their future expected cost structures into present hiring decisions.

But suppose some firms in a sector underestimate their exposure to future falling profits. These firms believe they can afford to pay more in wages, and so insofar as firms are competing for employees, they will succeed in attracting more workers than firms that are more sanguine about future profits, and certainly moreso than those firms that are overly pessimistic about the future of their market.

But suppose some shock does his that sector, and profit margins do fall. Wage-earners in that sector have become overly concentrated in those firms that are least prepared to weather hard times.

A parallel exists in reproductive competition between organisms that have many offspring and those that have fewer, hardier offspring. Rapid reproduction is essentially an optimistic action: as long as times are good, the species can be fruitful and multiply. But if hard times do strike, the more pessimistic approach to reproduction proves itself superior, and if a bad year follows an extended period of plenty (or in economic terms, an investment bubble pops) the overall effect on the ecosystem can be profound.

Posted by: Cyrus at Nov 8, 2006 5:46:08 PM

Diabetes, hypertension, heart diseases and arthritis are the common causes behind erectile dysfunction. Most of the popular ED pills fail to give a strong erection under these physical conditions. Do you think you can combat ED with any type of ED pill? I am afraid the answer it NO. When you have erectile dysfunction along with certain physical conditions, only levitra can help you out. It is the strongest pill to guarantee an erection. This is so popular a pill that you can order levitra while you are at home and get even cheap levitra compared to which you buy from the chemist. So, it is the time to buy levitra without spending much time and effort. Why do you wish to get it outside when you can buy levitra online and avail the best deals on the net? No way!

Posted by: levitra at Nov 15, 2006 4:03:21 AM

Non-monetary inflation can be stopped.

"People today use the term `inflation' to refer to the phenomenon that is an inevitable consequence of inflation, that is the tendency of all prices and wage rates to rise." Ludwig von Mises - "Inflation: An Unworkable Fiscal Policy".

All prices do not rise. Only the prices of variable real value non-monetary items while many constant real value non-monetary items are not fully updated and many are not updated at all.

The second inevitable consequence of inflation is the tendency of many constant real value non-monetary items NOT to rise at all - during the Historical Cost era while some constant real value non-monetary items are not fully updated.

Inflation today has and always had a second consequence during the 700 year old Historical Cost era.

Inflation has a monetary consequence, called cash inflation refered to above by Ludwig von Mises and defined as the economic process that results in the destruction of real economic value in depreciating money and depreciating monetary values over time as indicated by the change in the Consumer Price Index.

Inflation´s second consequence is a non-monetary consequence defined as Historical Cost Accounting inflation which is always and everywhere the destruction of real economic value in constant real value non-monetary items not fully or never updated (increased) over time due to the use of the Historical Cost Accounting model or any other accounting model which does not allow the continuous updating (increasing) in constant real value non-monetary items in an economy subject to cash inflation.

Inflation´s second consequence is solely caused by the global stable measuring unit assumption.

The stable measuring unit assumption means that we regard the annual destruction of a portion of the real value of our monetary unit by cash inflation in low inflation economies as of not sufficient importance to update the real values of constant real value non-monetary items in our financial statements.

This results in the destruction of at least $31bn in the real value of Dow companies´ Retained Income balances each and every year. Globally this value probably reaches in excess of $200bn per annum for the real value thus destroyed in all companies´ Retained Income balances.

The International Accounting Standards Board recognizes two economic items:

1) Monetary items: money held and "items to be received or paid in money" – in terms of the IASB definition.

2) Non-monetary items: All items that are not monetary items.

Non-monetary items include variable real value non-monetary items valued, for example, at fair value, market value, present value, net realizable value or recoverable value.

Historical Cost items valued at cost in terms of the stable measuring unit assumption are also included in non-monetary items. This makes these HC items, unfortunately, equal to monetary items in the case of companies´ Retained Income balances and the issued share capital values of companies without well located and well maintained land and/or buildings or without other variable real value non-monetary items able to be revalued at least equal to the original real value of each contribution of issued share capital.

The stable measuring unit assumption thus allows the IASB and the Financial Accounting Standards Board to conveniently side-step the split between variable and constant real value non-monetary items. This is a very costly mistake in low cash inflation economies - or 99.9% of the world economy.

Retained Income is a constant real value non-monetary item, but, it has been in the past and is, for now, valued at Historical Cost which makes it, very logically, subject to the destruction of its real value by cash inflation in low inflation economies - just like in cash.

It is an undeniable fact that the functional currency's internal real value is constantly being destroyed by cash inflation in the case of low inflation economies, but this is considered as of not sufficient importance to adjust the real values of constant real value non-monetary items in the financial statements – the universal stable measuring unit assumption which is the cornerstone of the Historical Cost Accounting model.

The combination of the implementation of the stable measuring unit assumption and low inflation is thus indirectly responsible for the destruction of the real value of Retained Income equal to the annual average value of Retained Income times the average annual rate of inflation. This value is easy to calculate in the case of each and very company in the world with Retained Income for any given period.

Everybody agrees that the destruction of the internal real value of the monetary unit of account is a very important matter and that cash inflation thus destroys the real value of all variable real value non-monetary items when they are not valued at fair value, market value, present value, net realizable value or recoverable value.

But, everybody suddenly agrees, in the same breath, that for the purpose of valuing Retained Income – a constant real value non-monetary item – the change in the real value of money is regarded as of not sufficient importance to update the real value of Retained Income in the financial statements. Everybody suddenly then agrees to destroy hundreds of billions of Dollars in real value in all companies´ Retained Income balances all around the world.

Yes, inflation is very important! All central banks and thousands of economists and commentators spend huge amounts of time on the matter. Thousands of books are available on the matter. Financial newspapers and economics journals devote thousands of columns to the discussion of the fight against inflation.

But, when it comes to constant real value non-monetary items:

No sir, inflation is not important! We happily destroy hundreds of billions of Dollars in Retained Income real value year after year after year.

However, when you are operating in an economy with hyperinflation, then we all agree that, yes sir, you have to update everything in terms of International Accounting Standard IAS 29 Financial Reporting in Hyperinflationary Economies: Variable and constant real value non-monetary items.

But ONLY as long as your annual inflation rate has been 26% for three years in a row adding up to 100% - the rate required for the implementation of IAS 29. Once you are not in hyperinflation anymore (for example, Turkey from 2005 onwards), then, with an annual inflation rate anywhere from 2% to 20% for as many years as you want, you are prohibited from updating constant real value non-monetary items. Then you are forced by the FASB´s US GAAP and the IASB´s International Accounting Standards and International Financial Reporting Standards to destroy their value again – at 2% to 20% per annum - as applicable!

For example:

Shareholder value permanently destroyed by the implementation of the Historical Cost Accounting model in Exxon Mobil’s accounting of their Retained Income during 2005 exceeded $4.7bn for the first time. This compares to the $4.5bn shareholder real value permanently destroyed in 2004 in this manner. (Dec 2005 values).

The application by BP, the global energy and petrochemical company, of the stable measuring unit assumption in the accounting of their Retained Income resulted in the destruction of at least $1.3bn of shareholder value during 2005. (Dec 2005 values).

Royal Dutch Shell Plc, a global group of energy and petrochemical companies, permanently destroyed $2.974 billion of shareholder value during 2005 as a result of their implementation of the stable measuring unit assumption in the valuation of their Retained Income. (Dec 2005 values).

Revoking the stable measuring unit assumption is actually allowed this very moment by IAS 29 but ONLY for companies in hyperinflationary economies. At 26% per annum for three years in a row, yes! At any lower rate, no!

It is prohibited by US GAAP and IASB International Standards for companies that are operating in a low inflation economy.

That means the following at this very moment in time: Today all companies in, most probably, only Zimbabwe (1000% inflation) are allowed to update all their variable real value non-monetary items as well as all their constant real value non-monetary items.

But not the rest of the world.

The rest of the world is forced by current US GAAP and IASB International Standards to destroy their/our Retained Income balances each and every year at the rate of inflation because of the implementation of the stable measuring unit assumption whereby we are all forced to regard the change in the value of the unit of account - our low inflation currencies - as of not sufficient importance to update the real values of constant real value non-monetary items in our financial statements.

We are forced to destroy them year after year at the rate of inflation till they will reach zero real value as in the case of Retained Income and the issued share capital values of all companies with no well located and well maintained land and/or buildings at least equal to the original real value of each contribution of issued share capital.

The 30 Dow companies destroy at least $31bn annually in the real value of their Retained Income balances as a result of the implementation of the stable measuring unit assumption. Every single year.

Retained Income can be paid out to shareholders as dividens. Poor Dow company shareholders. They will never see that $31bn of dividens destroyed each and every year.

We have all been doing this for the last 700 years: from around the year 1300 when the double entry accounting model was perfected in Venice.

When we do this at the rate of 2% inflation ("price stability" as per the European Central Bank and as per Mr Trichet, the president of the ECB) we are forced to destroy 51% of the real value of the Retained Income balances in all companies operating in the European Monetary Union over the next 35 years - when that Retained Income remains in the companies for the 35 years - all else except cash inflation being equal.

Each and every one of those 35 years will be classified as a year of "price stability" by the ECB and Mr Trichet. Mr Trichet will not be the president of the ECB in 35 years time.

I think we will do ourselves a great favour by revoking the stable measuring unit assumption as soon as possible.

FREE DOWNLOAD : You can download the book "RealValueAccounting.Com - The next step in our fundamental model of accounting." on the Social Science Research Network (SSRN) at http://ssrn.com/abstract=946775

--------------------

Nicolaas J Smith
http://www.realvalueaccounting.com/


Posted by: Nicolaas J Smith at Jan 10, 2007 2:04:18 AM

prescription pharmacy online prescription pharmacy online

Online Pharmacy cheap online pharmacy store
Order Generic drugs Buy Generic drugs without prescription

breast enhancement increase breast

loose weight without diets loose weight without diet

Posted by: pharmacy online at Feb 27, 2007 4:59:38 AM

google排名 google左侧排名 google左侧排名 google左侧排名 google左侧排名 google排名 google排名 google左侧排名 网站建设,网站推广 储罐,提取罐,配液罐,浓缩器,浓缩罐 简历 上润 翻译公司 电磁阀 安检门 金属探测器 离心机


反应釜,真空干燥箱,提取罐,配料罐 反应釜 真空干燥箱 提取罐 酒精回收塔,中药提取设备,双效浓缩器,单效外循环浓缩器 酒精回收塔 中药提取设备 不锈钢储罐,小型提取浓缩机组,低温提取浓缩机组,热回流提取浓缩机组 不锈钢储罐 安检门 金属探测器 金属探测器 手持金属探测器 地下金属探测器 金属探测门 金属探测仪 安检门,金属探测器,金属探测门,金属探测仪,手持金属探测器,地下金属探测器 金属探测器,手持金属探测器,地下金属探测器 防盗探测器,金属探测器,防盗报警器,工厂防盗设备,搜身工具


Nonwoven advertising bags Nonwoven bag Advertising aprons Nonwoven bags,Nonwoven Fabrics bag aprons,Waterproof aprons Nonwoven Shopping Bag Nonwoven gift bag search engine optimization 无纺布袋 无纺布广告袋,无纺布礼品袋 围裙,广告围裙,pvc围裙 制冷配件 蒸发器 制冷设备 冰水机 冷却塔 冷冻机 冷水机 雷蒙磨 直流电源 逆变电源 太阳能发电


thermoforming machine thermoforming machine,thermoforming Equipment thermoforming machine plastic sheet unit,Puncher Machine,PET/PP/PS Extrusion Line puncher machine plastic sheet making line pet continuous crystal dryer paper cup machine,paper cone machine,paper bowl machine paper cup machine paper cone machine cone winding machine packing machine paper bowl machine


储罐 反应釜,热回流机组,中药提取设备 中药提取设备 反应釜 酒精回收设备,酒精回收浓缩器 酒精回收设备 乳化机,小型提取浓缩设备,微型提取浓缩设备 乳化机 工业设计 外观设计 产品设计 网络摄像机 无线网络摄像机 视频服务器网络摄象机 昆明广告 昆明广告公司 云南广告公司 短信群发


直流稳压电源 直流电源 充电机 变频电源 稳压器 雪糕锥形纸筒成型机,纸碗外套粘合机,给袋式包装机 纸杯机 纸碗机 锥形纸杯机 触摸屏维修 上海收银机 记录仪 温度记录仪 温湿度记录仪 灯头 google排名 google排名 鹿茸 鹿茸 收银机

Posted by: google排名 at Jul 26, 2007 3:03:20 PM

power leveling power leveling powerlevelingpowerleveling wow powerleveling wow powerleveling world of warcraft powerleveling world of warcraft powerleveling world of warcraft power levelingworld of warcraft power leveling world of warcraft power leveling power leveling power leveling


wow power leveling powerleveling powerleveling wow powerleveling wow powerleveling wow power leveling wow power leveling world of warcraft powerleveling world of warcraft power leveling Yahoo Optimization Google Optimization MSN Optimization

Posted by: google排名 at Jul 26, 2007 3:04:36 PM

generic protonix buy generic protonix medication online
generic zantac buy zantac online
headache medication buy headache medication online
generic imitrex buy generic imitrex online
heartburn medication buy heartburn medication online
generic acipex buy generic aciphex online
generic nexium buy generic nexium online
Zyrtec Online Zyrtec Online

Posted by: lisa at Sep 30, 2007 2:32:14 AM

hotly girls video webcam girls hot webcam girls

good luck

Posted by: Tobis at Jan 23, 2008 3:59:43 PM

It's cool site please visit our site.
http://www.shopeastwest.com/med

Posted by: tom at May 12, 2008 6:05:27 AM

http://www.prospect.org/csnc/blogs/ezraklein_archive?month=04&year=2007&base_name=thronekissers&40

Posted by: wowgold at Feb 27, 2009 9:29:26 PM

Weight loss is easier than you think!

Adipex
Phentermine

Posted by: adipex at Mar 4, 2009 5:13:53 PM

興信所 エステ 探偵学校 不動産 東京 ビジネスフォン パーティー インプラント 離婚 東京不動産 大阪 賃貸 経営 コンサルティング  WEBシステム開発
ホームページ制作

Posted by: xcv at Jul 27, 2009 2:52:40 AM

不動産会社 コスメ 産婦人科 病院 歯医者 化粧品 脱毛 ダイエット グルメ エステ 引越 ホテル 温泉 永久脱毛 歯科 植毛 増毛 マンション 美容整形 美容院 美容室ペットショップ 税理士 予備校 小児科 理容院 内科 旅行 動物病院 旅館 結婚相談所 結婚式場 お見合いパーティー ネイルサロン 探偵 興信所 英会話 老人ホーム 証券会社 外科 家庭教師 幼稚園 弁護士 司法書士 受験 ラブホテル 学習塾 介護施設 注文住宅 パーティー リフォーム 設計事務所 宗教団体 小児歯科 デイサービス 葬儀場 質屋 リサイクルショップ 大学受験 グループホーム 建設会社 中学受験 レーシック 専門学校 ラーメン エステティックサロン ケータリング ダイエット食品

Posted by: xcv at Aug 6, 2009 11:48:50 PM

不動産会社 コスメ 産婦人科 病院 歯医者 化粧品 脱毛 ダイエット グルメ エステ 引越 ホテル 温泉 永久脱毛 歯科 植毛 増毛 マンション 美容整形 美容院 美容室ペットショップ 税理士 予備校 小児科 理容院 内科 旅行 動物病院 旅館 結婚相談所 結婚式場 お見合いパーティー ネイルサロン 探偵 興信所 英会話 老人ホーム 証券会社 外科 家庭教師 幼稚園 弁護士 司法書士 受験 ラブホテル 学習塾 介護施設 注文住宅 パーティー リフォーム 設計事務所 宗教団体 小児歯科 デイサービス 葬儀場 質屋 リサイクルショップ 大学受験 グループホーム 建設会社 中学受験 レーシック 専門学校 ラーメン エステティックサロン ケータリング ダイエット食品

Posted by: xcv at Aug 6, 2009 11:49:03 PM

Vietnam lies on the eastern seaboard of the Indochinese peninsula. It borders Chine in the north. Laos and Cambodia in the west, and looks out on the East Sea (ロールケーキ) in the east and south.

Posted by: linhvnn at Sep 29, 2009 12:02:58 AM

Post a comment