« Private spam regulation? | Main | Should couples keep separate finances? »

Let the Dog Out!

Dog the Bounty Hunter was arrested and jailed recently on charges related to his capture of Andrew Luster in Mexico.  Here's a couple of paragraphs from a long-term project:

Andrew Luster had it all, a multi-million dollar trust fund, good looks, and a bachelor pad just off the beach in Mussel Shoals, California. Luster, the great-grandson of cosmetics legend Max Factor, spent his days surfing and cruising the clubs. His life would have been unremarkable if sad had he not had a fetish for sex with the unconscious. When the first woman alleged rape, Luster claimed mutual consent but the videotapes that the police discovered when they searched his home told a different story. Eventually more than ten women came forward and Luster was convicted of twenty counts of rape and sentenced to 124 years in prison. There was only one problem. Luster could not be found.

Shortly before he was expected to take the stand, Luster withdrew funds from his stock accounts, arranged for his dog to be taken care of and skipped town on a one million dollar bail bond. The FBI put Luster on their Most Wanted list but months passed with no results. In the end, the authorities never found him.  But Luster but he was brought to justice - by a dog. Duane Chapman, now known by the title of his television show, Dog: The Bounty Hunter, had been tracking Luster for months. He picked up clues to his whereabouts from old phone bills and from Luster’s mother who inadvertently revealed that Luster spoke fluent Spanish. Finally, a tip from someone who had seen Dog on television brought Dog to a small town in Mexico with great surfing. Days later Dog spotted Luster at a taco stand and made the arrest.

Unfortunately for Dog, bounty hunting is illegal in Mexico and the US authorities, who in my opinion are embarrassed by their failure to capture Luster, haven't tried to intervene with the Mexican government to let the charges drop in the interests of justice.

For more on the effectiveness of bounty hunters versus the police see my paper.

Posted by Alex Tabarrok on September 18, 2006 at 07:15 AM in Current Affairs | Permalink

Comments

Doesn't this only work with non-celebrities?

Posted by: bhauth at Sep 18, 2006 7:26:27 AM

instructive to note that the very fact that fbi put him on a most wanted list is to attract attention to him & use public help to arrest him. the fbi like all other orgs can't devote equal resources to all problems. it shoudl really lool to bounty hunters for use in select cases, although extradition & legal hassles(like here) could be a problem.

Posted by: sa at Sep 18, 2006 8:30:38 AM

I am inclined to believe that this arrest and extradition is politically motivated, or a cover for some other scandal not being covered in the US media. The incident happened 3 years ago (and he was arrested by the Mexicans then), why is Mexico getting hot and bothered now? Mexicans aren't thrilled about capital punishment in the US, perhaps this is a proxy for disputing someone else's pending execution?

However, this isn't the first time a bounty hunter has gone to Mexico and been arrested. Bounty hunting isn't legal in many countries, so the admonition "if you can't do the time, don't do the crime" comes to mind.

Posted by: Peter at Sep 18, 2006 9:31:40 AM

The fact that the Mex. authorities are upset that someone violated their national sovereignty is laughable.

Posted by: Chris Meisenzahl at Sep 18, 2006 10:43:20 AM

IMHO the more laughable your sovereignty is, the more you get upset about it being violated.

Posted by: DK at Sep 18, 2006 10:52:50 AM

I'm glad Luster's in the pokey where he belongs.

But I think it's fantastic that the bounty hunter is behind bars as well.

Other than that's he is supposed to be on "our" side, he's as bad as the people he hunts down. (

Does every bounty hunter look like a wife-beating trailer trash scumbag or is that the work of Hollywood costume-designers?)

I don't believe in privatizing the criminal justice system.

Posted by: Auto at Sep 18, 2006 11:21:36 AM

Hmm..Auto, you say he's as bad as the people he hunts down and your proof is his looks? I always thought fashion police was a euphemism.

Posted by: asiequana at Sep 18, 2006 11:31:07 AM

[Finally, a tip from someone who had seen Dog on television brought Dog to a small town in Mexico with great surfing.]

Didn't Dog parlay his 15 minutes of fame from this this very episode into a tv show? I think the story goes that someone Dog knew saw Lusters picture on television and recognized him as someone they had seen in Mexico.

Posted by: Greg Hamer at Sep 18, 2006 12:04:18 PM

Details are below. Note that Condoleeza Rice will make the final decision. The November elections are close. Both Mexico and the US have a chance to look patriotic, while attaining the right result.


"The arrest warrant is under seal, and charges are expected to be announced Friday when Chapman is scheduled to appear before a magistrate's court in Honolulu.

Larry Butrick, chief of the criminal division of the U.S. attorney's office in Hawaii, said Chapman was arrested by Mexican authorities in June 2003 on charges of illegal detention and conspiracy.

The magistrate will determine whether Chapman can be extradited to Mexico, and the final decision will be made by the U.S. secretary of state, according to the U.S. attorney's office in Hawaii."

Posted by: Eric Rasmusen at Sep 18, 2006 1:34:17 PM

If a Mexican bounty hunter tracked down a Mexican serial rapist on American soil, would you have a problem with that?

Can't say that I would be.

Posted by: Steve at Sep 18, 2006 4:31:11 PM

I can not belive that a man who is looking out for the
American people by capturing a wanted fugitave. Andrew
Luster was a problem to our society by raping the women
his capture was well needed. I am glad that Dog was
there to arrest this man. I can not belive that the
American goverment will not do any thing to help this
man and his family. Why wont they help a man who helped
them.

Posted by: Becky at Sep 20, 2006 9:58:34 PM

So Dog jumped bail in Mexico.
And the Mexican Govt went through the proper channels to have a bail jumper arrested and returned.
Somewhere the God of Irony is having a good day.

Posted by: CK at Sep 21, 2006 11:52:45 AM

I agree with many of the people writing in that something smells fishy!! What does Bush & others in his
administration have against our own citizens. What does Mexico have against Bush etc??? This must really
be big if we can't protect our own citizens. I feel that we should not allow any Mexicans in this country,
legally or not. Tell the corrupt Mexican government to "stick this one where the sun doesn't shine". If
Condolezza Rice is to make the decision, God forbid if anyone that contradicts her gets in the same or
similar predictament. We will probably overrun the Mexican jail. I personally will never buy anything
that is made in Mexico & I definately will not visit. The country never appealed to me anyway.

We, as American citizens, must demand the permanent release of Dog Duane Chapman, Leland Chapman & Tim
Chapman.

I wish the Chapmans & the families involved the best & have faith in God, & he will see that everything
is fine.

We are praying for you!!!!

Love all of you!!!

Posted by: Jeane at Sep 25, 2006 2:07:33 AM

I think that this whole situation is really politically motivated. If you do not agree with me than you really need to wake up. Is it just me or is there a big coinsidence that the DOG is arrested shortly after the vote came in to build a wall on the border with Mexico? The mexican Government has already expressed that they do not like our new fence plan. This new fence hurts their country because of illegals entering our country and working. They send money home which helps their countries economy. The other fact is that DOG is a superstar with his TV show. When you add both of these together at this time you get a country that wants to strike back at the US for passing a bill to make a fence.

I hope DOG wins his case, but Mexico will probably use the new fence to stop the extradition of DOG.

Posted by: Dano at Sep 30, 2006 11:23:35 AM

The poster calling himself "auto" is clearly a retard. Hopefully the men in the white coats can track him down and return him to his padded cell before he hurts himself!

Since when does the US take orders from a corrupt country like Mexico? They harbor rapists, cop killers and all sorts of criminal trash over there! Why would the US agree to this nonsense? Since when do the constitutional rights of an American citizen get violated in order to appease a bunch of crooked scumbags in Mexico?

Screw you Mexico! You'll NEVER get The Dog!!!

Posted by: NightHunter at Oct 12, 2006 10:22:34 AM

Don't worry when Dog is in Mexico Prison his new boyfriend will be prettier than Beth. They will love Dog with his bleached hair. BOOYA!

Posted by: Dayfisher at Oct 22, 2006 2:52:16 AM

With all of this illegal immigration, I find it ironic that the many of the Hispanic population claims that they are not criminals because border hopping is only a misdemeanor, yet god-forbid anyone who commits a misdemeanor in their country.

I lived in Brazil for a couple of years where I’ve talked with many people whom attempted to cross our borders through Mexico. I spoke with one lady whom told me how her caravan was stopped by Mexican Police Officials. Knowing they were about to sneak across the borders, the Mexican Police forced everyone to give them money as a bribe. As soon as everyone paid up the police pointed them in the right direction. After talking with other Brazilians, whom also attempted to cross our Mexico border, I found many with a similar story.

So I find it interesting how the USA is demanded to adhere to all Mexico laws and treaties, yet they have no respect for ours. This whole thing with Dog Chapman has to be political.

Posted by: Hansen at Dec 5, 2006 2:10:28 AM

Well said, Hansen! You raise many valid points! Dog has somehow become a pawn in some sordid, international political game. It makes no sense for the US to play flunky to Mexico!

As for "gayfisher" and his moronic comment, since he seems to find prison rape so funny, I think he should go bunk with his boyfriend Andrew Luster. Now THAT would be funny!! ;)

Posted by: NightHunter at Dec 24, 2006 2:48:10 AM

sony pcga-bp3t battery

Posted by: at Oct 13, 2008 10:53:34 PM


Here suppling of a large number of cheap tiffany Jewelry,tiffany Replica Jewelry,Imitation Tiffany Jewelry and Knockoff Tiffany Jewelry,Silver Jewelry,925 tiffany Jewelry,Tiffany Silver Jewelry,So cheap!!!

Posted by: aion kina at Mar 20, 2009 4:05:34 AM

Post a comment