« Trip thoughts | Main | Markets in everything: The ten weirdest items sold on ebay »
The unit bias
Nominal variables matter, even when we are deciding how much to eat on our plates:
To test [the unit bias], the researchers left a bowl of M&M sweets in the hallway of an apartment building with a sign that read “Eat Your Fill: please use the spoon to serve yourself”. Some days they left a tablespoon-sized scoop, other days they left a quartercup scoop that was four times as big. Passers-by could obviously help themselves to as little or as much as they wanted regardless of which spoon was provided, but on average, 1.67 times more M&M’s were taken on the days the big scoop was left compared with the tablespoon-sized scoop.
In another experiment, the researchers found that, measured by weight, significantly more pretzels were taken by passers-by when a complimentary bowl of 60 whole pretzels was left in an apartment building, compared with when a bowl of 120 half-pretzels was left. And it was a similar story when either a bowl of 80 small Tootsie rolls (an American snack bar) or a bowl of 20 large Tootsie rolls was left in an office building.
In other words, throughout the study, people took more food when the unit on offer was larger. “Consumption norms promote both the tendency to complete eating a unit and the idea that a single unit is the proper portion”, the researchers said.
Here is further information. There is a lesson for macroeconomics in here, somewhere.
Posted by Tyler Cowen on June 28, 2006 at 02:43 AM in Science | Permalink
Comments
Were people supposed to eat 1/4 of a large Tootsie Roll and leave the other 3/4 of the Tootsie Roll back in the bowl?
Posted by: Hei Lun Chan at Jun 28, 2006 8:00:54 AM
If only they could've tried the experiment with LSD.
Posted by: Keith at Jun 28, 2006 8:05:21 AM
Doesn't this study show more about personal etiquette than personal consumption? In essence, the choice one makes when they are confronted with a set of free items which is being offered to the public. People will take as much as they desire without being (or appearing) selfish and taking more than their 'fair share'.
The more interesting statistic to track might be what percentage of the entire bowl of pretzels or Tootsie Rolls was taken by each free-sampler. Does the portion size decrease as the total amount in the bowl decreases? Or does it stay relatively constant?
Posted by: David at Jun 28, 2006 9:07:57 AM
Real Researchers would use broccoli.
Posted by: dearieme at Jun 28, 2006 9:27:32 AM
Yes. Stuff put out in public is one thing....people don't want to seem greedy. But I have a feeling, if anything, that broken pretzels and mini tootsie rolls disappear faster than their bigger compadres if they are consumed in an home environment. Too easy to say, just another tiny one...
Posted by: battlepanda at Jun 28, 2006 10:09:51 AM
Related to the question David asked - Heinz is packaging ketchup in larger bottles based on research that people squeeze out more ketchup when there is more left in the bottle (slide 18 of 28 of this presentation)
Posted by: Brian at Jun 28, 2006 11:17:18 AM
I think this, or something similar, is well-known in the grocery business. When goods are marked at say, 2 for $3.00, customers have a strong tendency to buy pairs, even though if price of one unit is $1.50.
Posted by: Bernard Yomtov at Jun 28, 2006 11:53:34 AM
"When goods are marked at say, 2 for $3.00, customers have a strong tendency to buy pairs, even though if price of one unit is $1.50."
This effect may be breaking down, though. I've noticed an increasing tendency for said offers to carry a minimum purchase clause.
As to the overall study, I wonder if you have to control for the period over which the good is consumed? I'm thinking about shopping at warehouse stores (i.e. Sam's, BJ's), where consumption on the basis of some "atomic" unit like weight would presumably be higher because of the larger number of atomic units per sales unit. But if I buy a package of 48 eggs at Sam's, I'm not intending to down them all over the same period as I'd polish off a regular 12-egg carton from Shoprite. Rather, I purchase 4 12-egg units to be consumed over 4 periods. There's a level of convenience that I'm purchasing along with the 4 consumption units at Sam's in that I cut out 3 additional trips. Something similar might apply to the Tootsie Roll and pretzel versions of the experiment. If the convenient unit for transportation purposes is one pretzel or one Tootsie Roll, you'd expect to see folks grab just as many transportable units and spread the additional consumption i terms of "atomic" units over more time. If I grab a big Tootsie Roll, I might eat half now and half later. If I grab a small Tootsie Roll, I may not come back later because a second trip is too much of a hassle.
Of course, the M&M version works against this, because presumably the larger scoop's worth is more of a hassle to carry around than the smaller one.
Posted by: Bernard Guerrero at Jun 28, 2006 12:52:16 PM
Isn't there also an effect from assuming that other people have some idea what they are doing? If everyone else is eating a portion of size X, then that is some (strong) evidence that size X is more-or-less appropriate.
Posted by: Jason Briggeman at Jun 28, 2006 2:14:30 PM
There is also a disconnect in this study between food taken and food consumed. How many people took a whole pretzel, ate half, and threw the other half away?
Posted by: Darren at Jun 28, 2006 3:05:46 PM
A small fixed cost per scoop regardless of scoop size generates the result without recourse to bias, no?
Posted by: Eric at Jun 28, 2006 6:50:10 PM
An important physiological consideration here is whether or not it is the number of swallows rather than the amount of calories consumed which controls the satiety response. That is, 20 swallows of half pretzels will probably make you more full than 10 swallows of full pretzels.
A non food-based example would obviously control for this.
Posted by: blah at Jun 28, 2006 7:06:20 PM
Outside the realm of food:
A newborn (human) child is called "large" if she's over eight pounds.
Or she's called "large" if she's over 4000 grams.
The thing is, one is 10% larger than the other. This isn't just nomenclature; it affects the observational and treatment protocol.
Tim
Posted by: Tim McG at Jun 29, 2006 11:59:14 AM
dandy vrouw ^^^ bisexueel mpgs ^^^ segretaria sex in pace ^^^ inchiodare fighetta ^^^ moyen esclave ^^^ ebene video ^^^ le plus frais fils mpeg ^^^ frais papa trente cinq ^^^ likable giovane urinate ^^^ stravagantemente amatoriali ass to mouth ^^^ radd av sig ung rovpuling ^^^ kallare elev grupperna ^^^ good ragazze dildo ^^^ deciso studentessa strip ^^^ sexy arschfick zunge ^^^ hardcore ligote ^^^ livesex imu porno ^^^ kalu ematin lumitilanne ^^^ i leilighet fantasi ^^^ henrivende gallerier ^^^ hetest snill fitter ^^^ mannlig paps ^^^ elkistikos lesvia praxi ^^^ amihanos gramateas striptiz ^^^ plus froid fils mpegs ^^^ plus chaude mama sequence ^^^ ripsokindinos mounohila ^^^ ripsokindinos vasilisa ^^^
Posted by: levan at Sep 11, 2006 2:42:46 AM
Hello all really cool blog
buy cheap alprazolam online buy cheap fioricet online buy cheap hydrocodone online buy cheap vicodin online buy cheap tramadol online buy cheap xanax online buy cheap valium online buy cheap ultram online buy cheap soma online buy cheap carisoprodol online buy cheap ambien online buy cheap ativan online buy cheap lorazepam online buy cheap propecia online buy cheap adipex online buy cheap didrex online buy cheap cialis online buy cheap levitra online buy cheap paxil online buy cheap meridia online buy cheap viagra online buy cheap wellbutrin online buy cheap clonazepam online buy cheap xenical online buy cheap prozac online buy cheap butalbital online buy cheap phentermine online
buy cheap ativan buy cheap adipex buy cheap didrex buy cheap levitra buy cheap cialis buy cheap phentermine buy cheap soma buy cheap tramadol buy cheap diazepam buy cheap carisoprodol buy cheap meridia buy cheap paxil buy cheap valium buy cheap xanax buy cheap ultram buy cheap fioricet buy tooth whitening buy online pharmacy generic alprazolam online buy car insurance buy payday loan list web directory list business directory free carisoprodol buy cheap hydrocodone buy cheap vicodin
Posted by: linda at Oct 9, 2006 8:21:41 AM
I just wanted to say WOW!!! goose bumps and e-motions, the design of your web page really got me!!! Check my sites ;)
Posted by: Andrew at Jun 2, 2007 5:39:08 PM
Where did you find this guestbook by the way??? I'd like to have one like this on one of my sites!!!
Posted by: Driser at Jun 3, 2007 5:37:04 PM
Knight Online Gold
Knight Gold
Knight Noah
Knight Online Noah
Posted by: aion kina at Mar 20, 2009 10:04:49 PM
aion gold
aion money
cheap aion gold
cheap aion money
buy aion gold
Mabinogi online gold
Mabinogi gold
buy Mabinogi gold
cheap Mabinogi gold
Mabinogi money
2moons dil
2moons gold
buy 2moons dil
2moons dil
cheap 2moons dil
flyff gold
flyff penya
flyff money
buy flyff penya
cheap flyff penya
cheap flyff gold
Dofus kamas
buy Dofus kamas
cheap kamas
Dofus kama
Dofus gold
Dofus money
Knight online gold
Knight Gold
Knight Noah
Knight online Noah
Posted by: aion at Jul 13, 2009 2:20:38 AM