« Robin Hanson's 'Myth of Creativity" | Main | Univision and Hispanic assimilation: a market test »

My favorite things Swiss

I am here only briefly, to talk about how America funds the arts.  Of course my favorite thing Swiss is Switzerland itself; in that sense I agree with the natives.  But to get more specific:

1. Sculptor: Alberto Giacometti is the obvious choice, runner-up is Jean Arp.  The smaller the Giaocometti sculpture, the better it is likely to be.  You could say the same for Calder.

2. Drama: I'll opt for Durrenmatt's The Visit of the Old Lady or The Physicians, or Max Frisch's Don Juan, or the Love of Geometry.  I like these better than any Swiss novel.

3. Painter: These days I find Paul Klee repetitive.  Arnold Boecklin and Ferdinand Hodler are both consistently interesting, if not always consistent.  Try this Hodler.  Here is the most famous BoecklinHenry Fuseli, who moved to England and became a perverse quasi-Romantic, remains underrated.

4. Novel: I don't know of a great Swiss novel, unless you count Rousseau's Heloise for its historical value.  Max Frisch's Gantenbein is one runner-up.  Robert Walser has his moments.

5. Music: This one gets tough.  Honegger bores me.  I will listen to Frank Martin, though he is not a favorite.  Paul Hindemith was of Swiss-German extraction but born in Germany.  He would otherwise win hands down.  Edwin Fischer was a wonderful Bach pianist.  Swiss popular music is too ghastly to contemplate, as is the folk music.

6. Actress: Can I say Ursula Andress?

7. Movie, set in: I still like George Lazenby's Bond movie, On Her Majesty's Secret Service.

Extra: You've also got Saussure, the Bernoullis, and the Eulers, not to mention Le Corbusier.  There is an overall inclination toward the mechanical, the scientific, and the systematizing.  Perhaps that is why music is so weak.

The bottom line: It is not just cuckoo clocks (as Orson Welles had suggested), which in any case do not originate in Switzerland. 

Posted by Tyler Cowen on June 24, 2006 at 03:40 AM in The Arts | Permalink

Comments

Cheese Fondue:-)

Posted by: Chairman Mao at Jun 24, 2006 3:58:36 AM

What about food? Fondue, anyone?

Posted by: bob tollison at Jun 24, 2006 7:04:57 AM

Cuckoo clocks? That's Schwarzwald in Germany (Black Forest) :)

If systematizing ruined a countries capability for music, then Germany hadn't created some beautiful musicians (J.S. Bach), because we also had some great engineers. I think that systematizing and an understanding of mechanics is (as is creativity a huge part of engineering!) essential to classic music, because it is more complex in structure and harder to understand than modern pop music.

While anybody can see the structure of let's say a Beatles song (Repetitve chorus pairs with stanzas and perhaps some solos), it is very much different with say Mozart's Requiem or Vivaldi's Four Seasons or Beethoven's Symphonies.
They are often multi-layered and very sensitive to themes and rearrangements, which makes them harder to listen to for some people.

Posted by: Max at Jun 24, 2006 7:58:05 AM

Hesse's house where he spent a lot of time and where he wrote many of his greatest novels.

Posted by: drtaxsacto at Jun 24, 2006 10:38:08 AM

For painter, how about Ernst Ludwig Kirchner. Born in Germany, but spent last 20 or so years of his life in Davos.

Posted by: Lance Knobel at Jun 24, 2006 2:12:36 PM

Swiss popular music ghastly??? Obviously you are
not aware of the mighty sportsguitar!!!!

http://www.pitchforkmedia.com/article/record_review/21979/Sportsguitar_Married_3_Kids

Posted by: kevin at Jun 24, 2006 2:49:55 PM

Athlete: Martina Hingis

- Josh

Posted by: Wild Pegasus at Jun 24, 2006 3:02:31 PM

"Der Besuch der alten Dame" is a great Durrenmatt play - but it's far better in the original German ;).

Posted by: Alex at Jun 24, 2006 6:52:34 PM

"Heidi" was like chicken noodle soup for me.

Posted by: Yan Li at Jun 24, 2006 7:15:13 PM

Im surprised you forgot Jean-Luc Godard. Some may detest his politics, or even his films, but there's no denying their brilliance.

Posted by: Brian Frye at Jun 24, 2006 10:56:44 PM

Many different Swiss mechanical watches for me: Omega, Rolex, Dufour, Patek, JLC, etc.

Posted by: Christopher at Jun 25, 2006 1:13:05 AM

My favorite Swiss cheese is Tete de Moine

Posted by: Paul N at Jun 25, 2006 9:51:09 AM

For composers how about Ernest Bloch or Heinz Holliger?

Fondue is not the Swiss national dish. Rösti is, a very fine simple dish is.

I'm surprised that you didn't mention that the World Wide Web was invented there.

Posted by: Dave Schuler at Jun 25, 2006 9:39:04 PM

Mmm, Rösti. I tried to make some after enjoying it in Geneva (I think), but despite its apparent simplicity it's not so easy to make it. Something to do with the starch in the potatoes. Though if I want to revisit the task now some eight years later I'm sure I can find suitable instructions on this other Swiss invention...

Posted by: bbartlog at Jun 25, 2006 10:06:22 PM

"Ulysses" was largely written in Zurich.

Posted by: dsquared at Jun 26, 2006 5:49:30 AM

Favorite things Swiss these days: the National Team. Even if you don't like soccer, you are in football-mad Europe right now, and and the very young and exciting Swiss team has a chance to go very far (I am writing this several hours before the game against the Ukraine). They will be one of the favorites in 2008 when they are co-hosting the next EURO.

Posted by: Stephan at Jun 26, 2006 5:59:13 AM

"Cuckoo clocks? That's Schwarzwald in Germany (Black Forest)"

In my days of selling cuckoo clocks in the Black Forest, I learned to distinguish between the Swiss-style cuckoo clock (painted in peasant motifs) and the Black Forest-style cuckoo clock (heavily carved and varnished). That is all I know about cuckoo clocks, then or now. I don't know which type is older.

Posted by: Chris Burd at Jun 26, 2006 12:36:55 PM

I find it kind of funny that the only song I know in French is by a band of German-speaking Swiss ("Tristesses de la Lune" by Celtic Frost). The French have done a lousy job when it comes to culture, at least the kind I'm into, which of course speaks ill of them rather than me.

Posted by: TGGP at Jun 26, 2006 12:56:14 PM

On whether fondue or rösti is the national dish, in Switzerland they talk about the rösti line: the border that runs between the German-speaking cantons and the French-speaking cantons (people don't usually talk about the Italian-speaking canton). Rösti on one side, fondue on the other.

For architects, Herzog and de Meuron are doing a lot of wonderful work these days. I think Mario Botta has gone off the boil a bit. And on writing Voltaire wrote Candide while he was living in Geneva. (And, come to think of it, Graham Greene's late stuff was written when he lived in Vevey.)

Posted by: Lance Knobel at Jun 26, 2006 2:08:22 PM

Tyler -- where are you speaking? I'm in Zurich for two days and would love to attend your talk. Email me back please! THanks.

Posted by: ben casnocha at Jun 26, 2006 2:26:26 PM

The "Physicians"? Shame on you, Prof. Cowen, that there was another Durrenmatt play with which I was unfamiliar, even if it was only for the second it took to click the link!

Posted by: Sub Specie AEternitatis at Jun 26, 2006 2:31:48 PM

Drama,

It is not "The Physicians." It is probably "The Physicists,"
indeed an excellent play, kind of a warmup for the more
recent "Copenhagen."

Posted by: Barkley Rosser at Jun 26, 2006 3:40:51 PM

Movie, set in:

Trois couleurs: Rouge

Posted by: frank dewith at Jun 27, 2006 6:35:50 PM

The Eulers? You mean there were more than one?

Posted by: Johan Richter at Jun 28, 2006 1:43:27 PM

grietje dronken vredig ^^^ serveerster kont in bad ^^^ emotivo ragazze ^^^ attraente lesbiche ^^^ bresilien photo ^^^ affection nympho merde ^^^ britannique dix neuf ^^^ papa images ^^^ retiring cowgirl ubriache ^^^ eccellere agente di polizia gruppo ^^^ kansla skolflicka dubbel fitta samlag ^^^ forsta klassens lesbisk kon ^^^ carino segretaria pompino ^^^ timorous giovane amore ^^^ megatitten analfick ^^^ vierge defonce omasex ^^^ mahayana orgasmi portto ^^^ penis siitin purenta ^^^ varmest sot ^^^ himmelsk mama ^^^ pornostjerne gallerier ^^^ modig videoer ^^^ prosinis servitora avnanismos ^^^ katapliktikos lesvia ^^^ pere trente six ^^^ quarante six insignifiant ^^^ ripsokindinos indi ^^^ ripsokindinos iaponeza ^^^

Posted by: levan at Sep 11, 2006 2:36:56 AM

Post a comment